Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

FWIW, I was there from the beginning, and stopped fairly quickly (maybe 20 or so hours in).

I hopped back in a couple years later after a few updates, and agree that the quantity of content was pretty big. But the quality was not -- it still felt "empty", and never held my interest long.

Last year, the same thing happened. I hopped back on after a few big updates, probably spent another 10 or so hours on it (I think I started over), and felt like I had explored all there was.

I feel like all the criticisms it gets are valid. I agree that the effort of maintaining a game after 10 years is incredibly admirable, especially since ever update has been free. That's amazing. And the devs should be acknowledged for that.

But the game itself still feels largely empty. The progression feels mostly repetitive without feeling like you're really moving forward in a meaningful way. And, as others have said, the proc gen still feels "vanilla".

I probably won't hop back in after this update. I've learned, by now, that while many praise the new content, it'll probably just feel like more of the same to me.

 help



To be fair, it sounds like you got a decent play time for a one time purchase ages ago. It’s ok not to love everything.

Personally, I like to do the expeditions, and then maybe a couple of hours after. It’s not the focus of my game library, but I enjoy the star seeing every now and then.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: